The oldest known tavern brawl in St. Pauli took place on July 6, 1734, right on the border with Altona.
At that time, Altona did not belong to Hamburg but had been under the rule of the Danish king since 1640. Hamburg, in turn, had anything but friendly relations with the Danes: the neighbor to the north repeatedly tried in vain to force the Hanseatic city to swear allegiance – it wasn't until 1686 that the Danes again marched against Hamburg, advancing with their soldiers to the Reeperbahn, but failing at the ramparts and withdrawing unsuccessfully after a few weeks.
In 1734, tensions were once again in the air, and Christian VI, King of Denmark, stationed soldiers in Altona, whom he accompanied personally.
In June 1734, His Majesty was therefore in the city of Altona, with its nearly 12,000 inhabitants, with about 6,000 men (in Hamburg, there were approx. 76,000).
At this time, across the border, approximately at the level of the "Mausefalle," was the tavern "Zum Hamburger Wappen." On the evening of June 15, 1734, a handful of Danish soldiers entered the taproom and, already drunk, demanded beer. When the maid initially refused – and then wanted to be paid in advance, the mood soured: "Only whores want money first," the Danish guests blustered – whereupon the innkeeper and a guest from the next table intervened. The situation escalated: the verbal argument turned into a full-blown fight, which grew into a riot. Hamburg and Altona dispatched more dragoons and infantry to the "Hamburger Wappen," where they encountered a mob that was demolishing the inn. In the melee, the armed Danes crossed the national border – then shots were fired, and a Hamburg dragoon fell dead from his horse.
The incident eventually landed on the desks of the Hamburg Council and the Danish King – but: who fired the shots was never truly clarified.